AUTHOR YEAR TYPE OF RESEARCH NUMBER OF PATIENTS SEX (M/F) MEAN AGE (years) MEAN FOLLOW-UP (months) BLOOS LOSS (mL) OPERATING TIME (minutes) UNION TIME (weeks) CLINICAL SCALES COMPLICATIONS (including non-union) INFECTION
Akalin[@138145] 2020 Prospettive 63 (A:33; B:30) A:17 M-13 F; B:24 M-9 F A:41.5; B:45 24 - - A: 16; B: 16 Dash Score A: 50.5-B: 44.6; Ases Score A:64.7; B:71.6 A:6/33 (18%)
B:6/30 (20%)
A: 0/33 (0%)
B: 2/30 (6.7%)
Benegas[@138146] 2014 Prospettive 40 (A:19;
C:21)
A:14 M-5 F; C:12 M-9 F A:38.4;
C:44.8
12 - - 7.2 (cumulative) Ucla Score A:31.2; C:31.4 A:3/19 (15.7%)
C:4/21 (19%)
A: 1/19 (5.3%)
C: 1/21 (4.8%)
Davies[@138147] 2016 Retrospettive 30 (A:15; C:15) A:10 M-5 F; C: 9 M-6 F A:46.7; C:48 12 - - - - A:8/15 (53%) C:1/15 (7%) A: 1/15 (6.7%)
C: 0/15 (0%)
Fan[@138148] 2015 Prospettive 60 (A:30; B:30) A:15 M-12 F; B:19 M-11 F A:39.3; B:39.2 12 A: 59;
B: 150.23
A: 59.53;
B: 90.93
A: 6.7; B: 10.6 Constant Score A: 90.20;
B: 90.33
A:0/30 (0%)
B: 3/30 (10%)
A: 0/30 (0%)
B: 0/30 (0%)
Heinemann[@138149] 2010 Prospettive 50 (A:25; B:25) A:21M-4 F; B:20M-5 F A:37.3;
B: 37.7
12 A: 140;
B: 310
A: 50.8;
B: 64.2
A: 13.6;
B: 15.2
Ases Score A:43.2; B:44.1 A:11/25 (44%)
B:9/25 (36%)
A: 3/25 (12%)
B: 8/25 (32%)
Kulkarni[@138150] 2012 Retrospettive 56 (A:31; B:25) 34 M; 22 F (cumulative) A: 39; B: 39 A: 10;
B: 12
A: 20;
B: 232
A: 65;
B: 112
A: 16;
B: 17
Ases Score A: 31.4; B: 29.04 A:10/31 (32%)
B:8/25 (32%)
A: 0/31 (0%)
B: 1/25 (4%)
Kulkarni[@138151] 2017 Retrospettive 112 (A:44; B:34; C:34) 83 M; 29 F (cumulative) 39.55 (cumulative) 12 - A: 117.95
B: 150.58
C: 131.71
A: 12.73
B: 13.58
C: 14.55
MEP Score A:excellent 21; good 23; fair 0; B:excellent 21; good 12; fair 1;
C:excellent 28; good 5; fair 1
A:15/44 (34%)
B:8/34 (23%)
C:4/34 (12%)
A: 0/44 (0%)
B: 2/34 (5.9%)
C: 2/34 (5.9%)
Lian[@138152] 2013 Prospettive 47 (A:23, 14 retrograde nails;
C:24)
A:16 M;7 F; C:15 M;9 F - A: 15;
C: 14
A: 195;
C: 147
A: 126;
C: 95
A: 16.8
B: 17.1
Ases Score A: 93.5; C: 98.2; Mayo Score A: 94.1; C: 97.6 A:7/23 (30%)
C: 4/24 (17%)
A: 0/23 (0%)
C: 0/24 (0%)
Putti[@138153] 2009 Prospettive 34 (A:16; B:18) 32 M; 2 F (cumulative) 39 (cumulative) 24 - - - Ases Score A:45.2; B:45.1 A:6/16 (37%)
B:3/18 (17%)
A: 0/16 (0%)
B: 1/18 (5.6%)
Zhang[@138154] 2020 Retrospettive 70 (A:34; B:46) A:19 M;15 F; B:31 M;15 F A: 43.3;
B: 40.1
A: 24.9;
B: 23.5
A: 206.8;
B: 355.4
A: 118.5;
B: 128.9
A: 13
B: 14
Dash Score A:23.8; B:22.4 A:8/34 (23%)
B:7/46 (15%)
A: 0/34 (0%)
B: 0/46 (0%)